- The Athletic Entrepreneur
- Posts
- Your Content Isn’t Broken But Something Is
Your Content Isn’t Broken But Something Is
The uncomfortable truth behind zero engagement.

Most people aren’t bad at content.
They’re just unintentional.
And unintentional content doesn’t fail loudly.
It just fades… quietly… with zero traction.
So let me ask you a few uncomfortable questions:
Are you posting, or are you publishing with intent?
Do you actually know who your audience is?
Do you know why you’re posting that piece of content?
Are you selling something — or just having fun?
Are you frustrated because nothing is converting?
Have you thought about quitting?
And the one nobody wants to answer honestly:
Are you engaging with other people’s content the way you want them to engage with yours?
If you hesitated on even one of those, good.
That hesitation is the signal.
Why Your Content Isn’t Converting
Let’s strip the excuses away.
Your content has no job Every post should know its role:
Attract
Educate
Build trust
Convert
Or warm people up for later
If your content doesn’t know its job, your audience won’t either.
You’re unclear on what happens next If someone follows you today and asks:
“What do I get from you?”
Would your answer be clean?
Confusion kills conversion.
You want engagement, but you’re not practicing it This one changed everything for me.
Before most people ever noticed my work, I was deep in the trenches:
Reading posts carefully
Leaving thoughtful, intentional replies
Adding context, insight, or perspective — not noise
Not chasing likes.
Not farming engagement.
Just showing up with intention.
That single habit quietly led to millions of impressions, long before my own posts started taking off.
People don’t engage with strangers.
They engage with familiar contributors.
If you want replies, be someone worth replying to.
Your style doesn’t match your goal Ask yourself honestly:
Are you emotional but vague?
Smart but distant?
Loud but unclear?
Virality without direction is just dopamine. Direction without emotion is invisible.
You need both.
You expect results without reps Content is training.
No athlete expects results without volume. No creator should expect conversions without consistency.
Most people don’t quit because it’s hard. They quit because they thought it would be fast.
The Reset (If You’re Serious)
If things aren’t converting, simplify:
Pick one audience you actually understand
Pick one problem you help solve
Decide one action you want them to take
Show up daily, even when it’s quiet
Engage before you expect engagement
Write like a human, not a pitch deck
And ask yourself the real question:
Are you here to build something — or just to be seen?
Both are fine.
Only one converts.
If you’re tired, frustrated, questioning yourself — good. That means you’re still in the arena.
The people who lose don’t wrestle with these questions. They disappear without ever adjusting.
Stay intentional.
Stay visible.
Stay in the work.
—
Michael Kennedy
@hoopstheoryx
Sign up for Beehiiv below
